The Atrómitos Way
Welcome to The Atrómitos Way Podcast, where we candidly discuss the everyday challenges facing safety net health and human service providers, government agencies, philanthropies, and advocates. Our podcast will offer practical, easy-to-implement solutions to long-standing and emerging problems and highlight innovative ideas from fearless thought leaders nationwide.
The Atrómitos Way
#018: Digital Defense: Cybersecurity in Healthcare
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Olivia Aréchiga from Data Tel Communications and the return Tina Simpson of Atrómitos highlight the severe impact of a cyber-attack on Change Healthcare in February of 2024, underscoring the vulnerabilities of the healthcare infrastructure. Olivia emphasizes the human element in cybersecurity, advocating for stronger individual responsibility, regular training, and a multifaceted cybersecurity strategy to protect patient data and healthcare services from evolving cyber threats and the potential dangers of AI innovations. The Change Healthcare cyberattack was a wake-up call for the healthcare industry, but what practical steps can we take to avoid a repeat?
Atrómitos Knowledge Hub Promo
--
This podcast is a production of Atrómitos, a woman-owned boutique consulting firm creating a better way for our health and human services provider clients to achieve their goals by strengthening internal operations, enhancing financial stability and evaluating public policies.
Want to know more about the firm behind the podcast?
- Atrómitos, LLC Website: https://atromitosconsulting.com
- Follow us on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/atromitos-llc/
- Subscribe on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@atromitosllc
- Get Emails: https://atromitosconsulting.com/atromitos-way/#subscriber
In addition to our podcast, we've developed additional resources to improve your understanding of both long-standing and emerging issues important to leaders in the health and human service provider, government and philanthropic sectors.
Our articles, policy briefs and infographics provide you with information you can use to reach your organization’s goals.
- Atrómitos Way Podcast Website: www.atromitosconsulting.com/atromitos-way
- Follow us on LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/showcase/the-atrómitos-way
- Articles: https://atromitosconsulting.com/atromitos-way/progress/
- White Papers: https://atromitosconsulting.com/atromitos-way/unlocking/
Welcome to the Adromedisway Podcast, where we have meaningful discussions on the challenges in healthcare and the solutions behind them. I am your host, Liz Church. Cybersecurity threats and the vulnerability of our healthcare infrastructure represent one of the greatest challenges to the integrity of our healthcare system. This was starkly demonstrated in the aftermath of the breach and ransom attack on change healthcare in February of 2024. This week we will delve into why cybersecurity has become a critical issue in healthcare, exploring how this threat has intensified due to decades of underfunding, technological advancements such as bad AI, and the insufficient regulatory oversight and industry accountability. Additionally, we will discuss the essential steps that healthcare practices should take to safeguard themselves, their patients, and their digital assets. Now, while cybersecurity is a technical vulnerability, executed and defended through technology pathways, it is important to remember that it is a fundamentally human problem and its causes and impact. It's an escalating problem because, as humans, we often postpone significant investments and reforms when immediate incentives and accountability measures are lacking. Today, back in the co-pilot seat, we welcome one of my favorite people, Tina Simpson, managing principal of Adromedas. Tina joins us today because we, you know, we can't talk about information privacy, security, and regulations without roping her in. Our guest today is Olivia Arachiga, a seasoned leader renowned for her expertise in crafting and implementing intricate technology solutions. With an illustrious career spanning nearly 13 years at Data Telecommunications based in Chicago, Illinois, she currently serves as the director of project and program management. And in this pivotal role, Olivia spearheads a diverse array of technological endeavors playing a pivotal role in meeting technology needs of numerous businesses. Data Telecommunications offers vast expertise and resources to guide clients through various technological domains, including cybersecurity. Without further ado, let us begin with the headlines. Olivia, can you describe what happened earlier this year with Change Healthcare?
SPEAKER_02Sure. So on February 21st, Change Healthcare was hit with a cyber attack that brought down its entire network and operating system for about a month. Now, this is specifically impactful because Change is a leading provider, if not the leading provider, of revenue and payment cycle management that connects payers and providers. It's essentially a powerhouse of data, of healthcare data and data management. It can't really be over-emphasized how big of an impact this has, both on the healthcare industry and also the cybersecurity world, understanding that according to Stat News, as they reported, it is one of the most vital payment networks in the country, electronically connecting 900,000 physicians, 33,000 pharmacies, and 5,500 hospitals with health insurers and providing other services. Now, that's a quote from Stat News. As of 2022, change facilitated 1.5 trillion in healthcare transactions. And the attack completely halted claims processing in hospitals and pharmacies. Now, what this really means is that these hospitals and pharmacies and physicians couldn't get paid. And when you're dealing with bigger hospitals and bigger organizations that have, I guess, a more robust financial system, they can sit without getting paid and those financial getting paid by those specific companies processing through change isn't as big as an impact. But for these smaller companies, the smaller hospitals, the smaller pharmacies, providers, this is a huge, huge problem. Some of them, there's been some reports that they may not make it. They may not be able to survive some of these, the financial impact that this has had. Now that's sort of the effect on the actual businesses themselves. So all of the healthcare information that's stolen, that's being in this has been reported lately. It's been, it's um, I guess I've seen different reports lately as to whether the data's been sold and or whether it's not been sold. So I can't say for certain if it's actually been sold on the dark web yet or if it's not sold yet. But in any event, assuming it is sold or will be sold soon to on the dark web, you're dealing with unbelievable levels of personal information on huge numbers of people. This includes social security numbers, your birthday, where you live, your main name, your, let's say, your children's birth records, your healthcare information. Um, all of that is highly, highly valuable to threat actors on the dark web and threat actors. So it's it's incredibly impactful. I have no doubt that it'll impact the way we look at healthcare infrastructure and management going forward, as well as how to manage cybersecurity in these huge linchpin organizations like change healthcare.
SPEAKER_01And if I could jump in here, and this is Tina.
SPEAKER_00I'm glad that we started here with talking about the impact of change healthcare because so often when we talk about cybersecurity, it's an abstract threat. It's something that may happen or it will happen to someone else. But here we have sort of like a case, but I it's going to be a case book study going forward of the dangers, first of all, that amount of consolidation of data within one entity and the vulnerability it creates, and then also the impact it has to across a network of this cascading effect. So Olivia mentioned the the number of provider practices not being able to make one month, two months without any without a significant portion of their revenue. But then you're also and change healthcare is I think the one of if not the primary pharmaceutical processing of prescription prescriptions. Thank you. That's the word.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. They do, and from notes that I found, they do at least 15 billion transactions a year.
SPEAKER_00So I mean that's a disruption, that's a direct uh disruption to the ability to deliver care, correctly. But also that it's not something that ends when the crisis ends. Olivia mentioned that there's this huge repository of data. We tend to think of getting our credit card stolen as being like, oh, that's the most immediate risk to me, but it's it's discrete. Here you have such a huge robust amount of data, there's no necessarily end to where it ends, right? What the risk is.
SPEAKER_02Right. You're gonna we're going to, like I said, assuming it's sold, and and what I'm referencing here is that a ransomware attack for context pulls down the network, takes all the data and holds it for a ransom and says, pay us this money, otherwise we're selling this information. And like I said, I've seen differing reports lately as to whether the information's been actually sold on the dark web. And honestly, I don't know, even if they reported that it wasn't sold, I don't know if I'd believe it. It's not like a situation where, okay, your credit card gets stolen, you cancel that credit card. This could have ripple effects, this will have ripple effects for years and years to come on the individuals whose data is compromised because these threat actors, the people that these scam artists, right, that that steal this information and use it, will reach out to you in two years and call you to try and authenticate your Amazon account. And they'll have all this information that makes it sound legitimate, and they'll use psychological tactics. And then you'll find yourself wiring $1,500 somewhere. And it's it's really insiduous. It's it's not able to be contained. You can't say where it's going to start and stop. You cannot say the total financial impact, both on the industry itself with healthcare or the individual. It's it's it's huge, it's it's massive. Um, like I said, there's really no end to where a cybersecurity breach like this will end. There's there isn't.
SPEAKER_00I feel like in this first question, we have definitely established that this is a BFD. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yes, absolutely. And there's a lot of different things that we can expand on this on a later date, but when it comes down to the individual, I feel like a lot of people don't understand exactly what is at risk. When they think of data, they they may not think of it how to how extent extensive is that data. Like, is it, oh, is it just my age, my address, or is it just who I am, where I go to my doctor, or anything like that? Like it's they don't realize at such a granular level, like that, like you said, they can be targeted for insidious acts later on. I think it I can just consider it being mindful and always careful whenever you're approached with anything that just doesn't seem normal. And I pride myself in always being skeptical every time I get some kind of like, hey, this is this, we're trying to reach you for this. And I'm like, who are you? How did you find me? And I think if you have that approach, you will always be able to be mindful of like, okay, can I be careful? Is this safe?
SPEAKER_00And I know that we're gonna get into this, so I don't want to jump the gun too much, but I think that that is like the if anything, the the target point of this conversation is that it's that human instinct to push the button. Um I mean, for myself, even in my profession as a or in my role as a chief compliance officer, there's still is something like, well, but maybe. Um so there's just it works on we, we are, we are, we humans are the big this is a human problem. It it plays on our humanness to that's that's the key.
SPEAKER_02I mean, the it's not a coincidence that the vast majority of cyber attacks are phishing and then remote desktop protocol, which remote desktop protocol is is the that that security's vulnerability is really a poor password, weak password situation. So a phishing attempt, as we know, is when you get, let's say, an email from what looks like a valid or trusted source with a link that says, Hey, I got this document for your review. Can you check it out? And you click on it and then enter in some information, and then they've got access to your network and your files and boom. Now, what this is is it's prying on your humanness, it's it's prying on that human level. And that's not a coincidence. It's because that human level is the most substantial and significant factor in cybersecurity. Um, that, like I said, phishing is is the number one way that these ransomware attacks are completed. Now, Change Healthcare hasn't acknowledged how the attack initiated, but I would put money on that it was a phishing attempt by just a regular any employee, just anyone. And the point isn't that that people are stupid or careless. Um, it's there's a lot that goes into it. It's it's resources, it's training, it's understanding. I mean, some people don't know what to do when they click on a malicious link or things like that. So, like Tina said, I know we're going to get into this more, but it's absolutely not a coincidence that it's that it's at that human level because that's the most role-bour level and that's the most successful level for threat actors to achieve what they want and get into your system.
SPEAKER_00And I think also as a huge it's a human problem. We're loath to give it a human solution. We are always looking for that silver bullet, a technology solution. Like this is going to be the gate or the great wall that stops everything.
SPEAKER_02And there isn't. There's no silver bullet when it comes to cybersecurity, and there shouldn't be. We don't want one solution. One solution would mean that you're a threat actor that would have one target to hit and say, this is this is the the solution that I have to break. If they had one thing, they're like, this is it, everybody, it works, we're done. No, you need to have a multi-layered approach with cybersecurity. And that requires a lot of understanding and having a good depth of resource for implementing and managing and maintaining a strong cybersecurity solution in your network. And with healthcare, you're dealing with a vast, huge number of not only people, but intricate systems that have to talk to each other and connect. And it's it's complicated. We need to embrace complexity.
SPEAKER_01I don't think anybody likes that.
SPEAKER_00But I know that's it's human not that's the human part.
SPEAKER_01So, I mean, so embracing complexity, we have to have a strategy to combat these things, correct? Like a real one, not the silver bullet kind of situations. Olivia, can you explain what you mean by a multi-layered cybersecurity strategy and why is it important besides protecting everybody? But why is it important to have this kind of thing?
SPEAKER_02As we kind of mentioned, it's a really I guess the easiest way I can describe it is you don't want to give the keys to the castle to one person. Having a single solution or one product or one cybersecurity product would say you've got one vulnerability, a huge vulnerability or entry point into your network and security systems, because there's there's just one product or one company. And let's say one company does it from top to bottom. That one company is a huge liability then, because that company controls everything about your cybersecurity solution. Um, layering your cybersecurity services and products is absolutely critical for any industry, not just healthcare. We've uh at that basic level, so at cybersecurity, you have, I guess you could say five levels. Um you have the identification level, protection, detection, response, and recovery. And you could say you can you can layer on at each one of these levels. Now, an example of the identification level would be your multi-factor authentication. So that's right, your your Okta, your Microsoft authenticator. Let's say you're trying to log in on a new device. And so it has you do an authentication via your Microsoft authenticator, or even every time you log in, right? Or single source sign-on, the SSO. So that's another on that protection identification levels where it requires you to sign on to a system or product from an authenticated source. And then you use that authenticated source. The point is that you have to have these various layers. Like at the firewall level, I'll just mention you have your firewalls looking out for malicious emails, and your your IT team, let's say, is writing rules so that it identifies hey, this email came outside of your organization. Be careful before you click on any links. You probably have seen this in some of your emails, either from your own organization or others coming in. All of these levels work together to keep it a secure network. You got to think about it as sort of these meshed layers on top of one another. And each one is is not going to protect the whole thing. And it can't and it shouldn't. But together it will. Now, I do want to manage, or I do want to mention that there's there's a managed solution providers are out there and they do a really, they can do a really nice job of managing everything top to bottom. But um, that's that's understanding they use a multiple stacks or multiple different products, uh, not just one company or one solution, but you do have another key. Right. You you have they're managing the entire thing for you. However, they're using multiple different solutions together. So that's also a good option.
SPEAKER_00And if I could add to that, by thinking of like the sort of like in any situation trying to control risk, you have this sort of recognizing a Swiss cheese later on. There's going to be holes. You want to create stop points or check control points so that one mistake doesn't lead to giving the keys over the kingdom away. As Olivia mentioned, there are five points sort of in cybersecurity identification, detection, et cetera. So just because if you miss them on the first one, you need to be able to mitigate the risk when they're lurking in the system. So it's sort of that constant vigilance across the continuum of your security system.
SPEAKER_01So, Tina, how do you perceive the distinct challenges faced by the healthcare sector in safeguarding sensitive patient information, particularly considering the life or death implications and the high value of such data on the dark web?
SPEAKER_00In the context of thinking of it's not as just the sale of information and that that's the harm. In the healthcare system, it's the not having access to the providers, the hospitals, the ability for dispatch to coordinate with the receiving ER department. It's access. And there's a reason that ransomware is so lucrative. It's not just because these covered entities are concerned about the fines associated with a data breach. It's the ability to continue operations. Cybersecurity is fundamentally a component part of the ability to deliver care. And we do have, there are instances when a hospital sort of offline that that impacts patient care. I size, I may be pronouncing it wrong, but two years, two or three years ago in 2021, did a report on a series of breaches that occurred during the pandemic. And while they didn't and couldn't come out and say there's definitively an increase in um uh in mortality or worse a bad outcomes associated with a cyber attack or a ransomware attack, they came pretty close to saying that. They sort of demonstrated that there is a rot, there was a general rise at those facilities at those health systems afterwards. Similarly, it kind of just stands to reason if you if your information security, if your information system is part of how you deliver care, not having access to that impacts care. Yes. Very well said, Tina.
SPEAKER_02Thank you. When I thought about this question, my thought initially, and this is speaks to your experience in healthcare regulation and government and law. And my initial thinking on this was how would it directly cause a life and death situation? And my thought process and understanding and experience went to, okay, we we see how AI is impacting not only healthcare, but cybersecurity and threats. We're going to see situations where I mean we we already have medical devices that are online and transmitting data to and from hospitals with a patient directly. We already have advanced robotic care. What happens when we get AI involved in this robotic care and we get a threat actor's ability to infiltrate that that care in the moment, an actual in the moment situation? And we know hospitals and healthcare centers have safeguards and backup power and all that, but at what level are they protected in terms of security and information management? And this is real kind of I guess sort of scary to think about. It's definitely not nothing that I guess I have any experience in. Um, but it that's what I think of is is what is there a future where we could see a threat actor's ability to actually infiltrate a device in the moment or bring down the power and the backup power and the tertiary power on a hospital situation. And like I said, these are real tough ideas to think about. But I think Tina's is is more in the moment and and I guess you could say impactful today.
SPEAKER_00What I've thinking of is this unfortunate terminator um type situation, which was the unfortunate thing is that we can we can and we are having a number of the situations that I've described that happen without really, we're not really aware collectively aware of the cost of our continuing to defer the idea of sort of establishing true minimum security standards across this the infra our healthcare infrastructure. Um but it as humans, our imaginations go to that terminator moment. We protect against the terminator moment, the idea of like that very focused intent, but usually when the harms that we usually experience actually are the less less direct but and harder to quantify, but just as if not more impactful than yeah, AI robots doing bad options, yeah, delivering bad care.
SPEAKER_02Right, right, exactly.
SPEAKER_01Kind of piggyback on that, Tina. So, like we're hearing about hospitals that have these breaches, the larger institutions and things like that. Would you say that the little guy, the little the smaller providers, even smaller health centers, they're also at risk? It's not just the big leagues.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. It may not make the headlines to the national headlines to the same extent, but I think that frequently smaller entities have have less sophisticated um solutions. Additionally, there is a very big difference between a health system's ability to budget for and plan for their cybersecurity and a rural, say a rural hospital. There's a this is we're very much operating in a time of a tale of two cities when it comes to our healthcare entities and their ability to their operational budget ability because we're in the age of rural hospitals not being able to continue. So when you're when it's between investing in this, this might happen and continuing to deliver labor and delivery things that are needed by the community right then, it's very easy to not um put you don't have the resources to put towards cybersecurity, and you definitely have more immediate needs, more tangible immediate needs.
SPEAKER_01And to add to that, this is Olivia here.
SPEAKER_02What you see in these um threat actors are um they're they're looking for opportunity. Yeah. So the rural hospitals, of course, are at risk, but it's that information is not nearly as valuable as, say, the information from change health care, really because of the size of it and the the the number of patients, so to speak, that a rural hospital sees or has records on versus change healthcare. Um and what you're in what we're seeing to go back to change healthcare is these rural hospitals are probably using change healthcare to process that information, anyways.
SPEAKER_00And I would like to actually, if I can jump on that, because change it additionally a little. You you touched on this that everything is connected. A rural hospital, it's got it's connected into an HIE, it's connected into change healthcare. It's this is a very big web. So nothing there, no man is an island, no entity is really an island in this context. So that's also the complexity of the problem we're trying to solve for. I'd like to you you mentioned Liz speaking from a regulatory perspective. I want to put a little bright spot here of what I think that is having having done all the doom and gloom. Um I think we are making progress. It's very, very slow, it's very, very overdue, but we are increasingly publicly legally recognizing cybersecurity as a core component of our of our infrastructure, of our collective security. Two years ago, or the Biden administration recognizing healthcare and a number of other sectors as part of infrastructure that uh the cybersecurity infrastructure we're mandating, reporting to size. And now going forward in terms of like working papers on establishing what are some minimum standards for hospitals, for example. Um, so it's it's overdue, but it is the necessary first step of recognizing that this is a problem that there's no silver bullet, and there's we haven't done a good job of holding the people with the not people, but the entities and the systems that have points of control really accountable for the cascading effects of under of historically underfunding investment in cybersecurity. And to this point, this is what you mentioned.
SPEAKER_02You in the they'll start issuing penalties for non-compliance starting in 2029 regarding the cybersecurity improvement in transitions, which is really interesting moving from um providing assistance to hospitals for cybersecurity to now issuing penalties.
SPEAKER_00I I will just I will just say that's one hell of a glide path. I mean, we are it's 2024. Yeah. We've got five years.
SPEAKER_01I feel like we do need to emphasize the role of human error and waiting so long for the transition of plans and the things that the Biden administrations are doing, this is great and whatnot, but like there is a lot of human involvement that's going to be required. It's kind of like when back when nuclear was being seen as like this is the new phase of power, this is this, this is that, and then we had all the catastrophic things that happened that were due to human error. This is the same thing, but we can't see what happens from this. There's no physical impact on anybody.
SPEAKER_00This is all the explosion.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, this is like this is invisible. This is it's impacting you on a level that no one's really ever seen before. And I think humans are more out of sight, out of mind. If I don't see it physically happening to me, it's not really that much of a threat. I think we need to highlight a little more like we need to fix this. Everybody needs to know.
SPEAKER_02It's real, I mean the cybersecurity and and and protecting our information and and hospitals and healthcare facilitators protecting their information and their networks, we've it's complicated and it's going to be complex, and it needs to be complex. It needs to be complicated because the threats need to be not be able to get in easily. Um so while there isn't, like we've talked about, there isn't one solution, there's not one training program that we can do. There are some honestly, truly very small and effective steps that any organization, small or large, can do that will make a definitive and significant impact starting on day one. And it's a hundred percent related to the human aspect, the the individual aspect. So we talk a lot about inside cybersecurity, the zero trust network, the zero trust policy. And without getting too barred down in all the fun technicals, it's really a perspective that every single entry point on your organization from your computer to the person on the computer is cannot be trusted. And not that they're literally untrustworthy, but that they themselves are an entry point for a threat. So to that perspective, it's it's again going back to those beginning levels of cybersecurity, the identification and protection. So having those multiple layers of identification to get into any system. Now, when you're dealing with healthcare, you've got information sharing platforms across the board. Just it's incredibly, you need to share this information, doctors and providers and specialists and billing and insurance. They need to be able to share information quickly, right? You've got lots of entry points and lots of access points for for or opportunity, right, for a threat actor, because there's so many points at which you could gain access, but you need to be able to share this information effectively. So what you're dealing with is two really competing ideas here. You want to be able to provide efficient, effective, easy care for your patients and your clients, depending on the industry we're talking about regarding healthcare. Um, and then you also need to be secure. Um what were the problem is that people, their goal isn't, they're not working in cybersecurity. Their goal is to help patients. So they're not going to be cybersecurity experts. If they have to change their password every 30 days, that's gonna be really annoying and frustrating. And it's it's gotta be 20 characters long with special characters and capitals, et cetera, they're gonna, it's gonna get really tough. So that human aspect is so it's not a single facet type of conversation you're having here. You've got to manage so many different competing ideals in this industry. But the fact is that because we're seeing these threats come in through phishing and mote desktop as the most common entry points, those vulnerabilities are literally just the basics of don't click on any links outside your organization and have strong passwords and change your passwords. Um, now this needs this can be administered and managed by your IT and network team on regular trainings, regular updates, required trainings and updates. I mean having a strong protocol. I think what we're I think one thing that gets overlooked a lot is people don't know what to do when they've done something wrong. And they don't know, like for example, I get phishing attempts. I mean, and sometimes I forget to report them, but you need you should send them to your IT team. And do you know who you should send them to? Do you know who they need to go to? Um, all those little those those kind of small, and I say small, they can be in reality, they this can be tough to implement, but it's not necessarily an expensive new product. It's not necessarily an expensive new system that you need to implement that's going to cost hundreds of thousands of dollars. This is dealing with your individuals on an individual human level and training them to understand how to deal with this, the the basics of information management on their level and securing the information and how they're managing it with strong passwords and and and ensuring that they can keep up with that. Like I said, because you're gonna see that fatigue from your users if you're requiring these robust password changes every month. And that's it's it's complicated, is the best way I can use the question because there's there's not you're with healthcare, you're dealing with competing ideals and it's tough.
SPEAKER_00That uh I couldn't have said it better. The they're recognizing that there is a direct conflict between the accessibility that you need in healthcare, access to information, and then security. It's human actions that are associated with like I'm pulling this from like 86% of cybersecurity incidents. It's a human act or a human vector and in context. Um, so it's not like the mission impossible just somehow doing magic things on the keyboard that gets them into you don't see like people like breaking into data centers and logging, like hacking into a router in a data center.
SPEAKER_02You know what I mean? Like they're not acting. That's not the way this happens. It happens at the human level most significantly or most often. Yeah, just like you're saying.
SPEAKER_01When you talk about all of these things and the trainings that people go through, and I know a lot of people in their brain they're like, Man, I gotta do this thing. But when you compare the doing the thing, being taught the thing, how much money you're saving. I mean, I don't I can't I don't have it in front of me how much this has cost the hospitals that have had their recent cyber attacks, but it's it's a boatload, it's a lot of money.
SPEAKER_00I think what our our friend freshman might say of cybersecurity is a shared responsibility. Too frequently, and whether any system, it's sort of IT is something that happens in a back room. There are no goblins in the computer and in the dark room. Yes, yes, and someone else handles it. Um but as Olivia was saying, everyone is sort of like an entry point, everyone has a responsibility. We don't necessarily thinking of training as sort of a check the box exam exercise when it's really what I've heard Olivia say is much more of like this evolving sort of dynamic awareness and awareness of the steps that you individually in your role and as a member of the team um can can take and must take.
SPEAKER_01And the the more that and it's Olivia here.
SPEAKER_02These individual members, the your everybody in the team understands how their direct actions impact, the more effective the message will be on understanding. I mean, because we all know the situation where you have to go through a quarterly training and you just click through it as fast as you can to get it done, and you're not really reading or paying attention. And it's like, is that really going to be an effective way to remind or update your team on cybersecurity practices and all that? And one thing we see is implement a cybersecurity solution, and one of those they'll do penetration testing. And let's say part of one of these things will be they'll send phishing messages, fake phishing messages to your team and see who clicks on it. And and that's part of the training exercise. And so there's some really amazing, great solutions out there that can solve some of these, the user fatigue, the lack of participation, so to speak, and actually understanding how you participate in your organization's cybersecurity.
SPEAKER_01So I gave the audience a brief overview in the introduction, but Olivia, can you explain what Datatel does in terms of addressing cybersecurity weaknesses and vulnerabilities for clients?
SPEAKER_02We were talking about these really great solutions that can solve some of these cybersecurity problems that you're seeing either amongst the team or a weakness and a vulnerability, or you've been you've had a DDoS attack or something like that. That's something that Datatel works with. And we we work with all of these organizations and our engineers to source and find and implement the right solution for our clients. So we have this experience in all sorts of technology types and client types of different industries as well.
SPEAKER_01That's a whole catalog of services right there. I will be making a resource that accompanies this episode. So we'll shed light on this entire conversation and provide a guide to help you, you listeners, to know what to look for, what it means, to learn more about data telecommunications in detail for what they provide to their clients. But as we pivot just a little bit, Tina, this question is for you. What are the critical aspects of the regulatory landscape governing cybersecurity and healthcare and how crucial is compliance with regulations like HIPAA in ensuring the protection of data and patient privacy?
SPEAKER_00Great question. I think we touched on some of this in my earlier rant on about how we haven't been great about sort of keeping pace with the reality of our digital ecosystem and having regulations that really take into account the cascading impact of data breaches. I also wanted our our ecosystem, our regulatory landscape really centers around HIPAA. HIPAA wasn't really developed with an idea of you couldn't really imagine where it would be 20 years on, 30 years on from its inception, the degree to which we're connected. It's also the the damage isn't just privacy-oriented, or it's recognizing increasingly that cybersecurity, our data infrastructure is an infrastructure. It's just like the roads that make good so that you can get from your goods from one coast to the other or the the airports. It's something that is a collective good. It is a utility. And we haven't invested in it in that context to that date. We also haven't, in my opinion, adequately apportioned sort of responsibility. Um we see this for to covered entities or to when it comes to cybersecurity practices. There's not been, in my opinion, adequate tailored regulation on that. I'm going to cite one an example in this context of Olivia was talking about like hospitals, health systems being such a target because that's where the information is. So like change healthcare. Why do you rob a bank? That's where the money is. And this is huge troves of information that's very valuable and also subject, you know, there's a great, you need to get it back. But even to date, there's a minuscule proportion of hospital health systems budget, of their IT budget that's dedicated to cybersecurity. Within the past five years, there was some study done about something like up to 80% of hospitals. And this this covers everything from the very large health systems down to very, very small rural hospitals. So like 80% of them didn't have a full-time member of staff equipped to address cybersecurity specific concerns. That's a big gap. It's a gap that is closing as more attention gets is drawn to this. But I think that that the fact that we aren't staffing up to what the threat and risk is is indicative of the fact that we're thinking of compliance in business terms, which means so regulatory compliance, you check the box. Have you done your security, you know, your annual security training for your people? Do you have a firewall? Are you meeting these really vague baseline measures? And there's not the incentive or the scrutiny applied to those that entities that have the most ability to, and I would say responsibility to beef up their security and their practices to put the money behind that because it's not, it hasn't been seen. It hasn't, we've we've kept, we've kept kicking it down the road, sort of like not having, not enforcing or giving penalties for not meeting minimum standards until 2029 under that infrastructure example. So that's that is that is my I think that we've got a lot of regulatory lag. There are many reasons for that. It's we've got regulatory lag in a lot of areas. Um, and that we we're in an evolving landscape and we we need to catch up. And the first step in catching up is recognizing that this is treating this more as a utility. Sunshine is the best disinfectant, and the degree to which we can quantify and make really clear these are the costs to society as a whole, to individuals, um, I think the better chance we have taking meaningful action on this. And for that reason, as terrible as change health care is, as catastrophic, it is a it's going to be a very important case study and I hope a turning point in the way we think of cybersecurity, because it it means real dollars for some big players. Um, it's disrupted the system and it gives it makes real what in many instances has sort of been a potential potentiality to too many people. That's to add to that.
SPEAKER_01This is Olivia again.
SPEAKER_02One of the reasons I think that cybersecurity and and not just in healthcare, you don't see the appropriate appropriation of funds and resources towards that is because the market, it's the market is is incredible regarding cybersecurity and and network services. It's almost like you can't throw a rock without hitting a new cybersecurity company. Reading that market and understanding what you need and understanding how to manage and how to facilitate your cybersecurity needs is hard and challenging and requires an expertise. And unless you have a CISO or chief technology officer, when a lot of organizations simply don't have the budget for that, you need experts to help guide you through that market. I'll plainly say, I mean, that's what Datatel does. We work with all these companies and we we vet them out and we we determine what's the best fit. And we don't recommend every provider or anything like that, especially if they're new on the market. We haven't seen them in their in real case, real life scenarios. And it's it's an ever-changing, ever-evolving, extremely lucrative business now. And you're a lot of these companies, it's it's it's basing this catastrophic, fearful perspective on what could happen to your business, what could happen to the information, you know, you're liable, et cetera, et cetera. But really understanding the fundamentals and what you need is is challenging and requires truly, it requires an expertise. Uh, and I don't think that that's it's not easily accessible to any to every single business. And I I don't think we can fault them for that. It's not, it's it's simply an outside expertise that your business doesn't deal in. And to obtain that is sometimes is is plainly impossible regarding in terms of budgets, especially for our small businesses. So as we're dealing with these regulatory changes and and the market evolves regarding cybersecurity, we're gonna see a lot of, I guess, a lot of disruption, a lot of change, a lot of uh companies coming and going, I think, especially as regulation picks up and we see a lot of change in that area.
SPEAKER_00So still have that zero trust and have some scrutiny when selecting your oh yeah, your yes. This also made me think of another thing when talking about regulation or what is most impactful with going back to change healthcare. The first entity or public entity that we had a sort of a public disclosure that we knew about from change healthcare, it was the security that was the securities commission. Um it was change healthcare was notified SEC. Okay, what um so that's how the news broke.
SPEAKER_02One thing that is when you're talking about banks and credit card information that we talked about earlier, it's that's tangible physical money that you're dealing with. Information is it's hard to to apply money factor dollar amount to that, but it is valuable, it has value. How we assess that and how we're managing that is in this capitalistic market economy is complicated because it's and that's partly what we're seeing with changes, is the the dollar effect on the individual as well as the the provider and the hospital network regulations and the the what we're seeing from the government is we've already seen regulation coming down in the banking and things like that, but in terms of information, managing information and protecting information, that's a whole other fit ballgame that we're just now getting into.
SPEAKER_01So then how do you think we can balance making health information accessible while keeping it secure? Like what can we do to help healthcare providers, government agencies, and then security experts work together better to protect against cyber attacks? Tina, you can answer this one first.
SPEAKER_00The first thing that comes to my mind is, and I of course I go to sort of regulatory component, I think that this is a security is a sort of shared responsibility. And everyone needs to have sort of that haskin in the game and needs to feel that. Here in Europe, health information is a is protected information regardless of the source of that. Whereas in the United States, we sort of have the stewardship model under HIPAA, where it's the covered entities that you go up the chain and and and the buck stops with at several points, but it's there's a limited universe of who can be held accountable for accessing, using, stealing information like that. So I think that one relatively simple change that needs to happen, that is important for privacy and security is that we moving away from the strictly stewardship model to one where you you have a right of of you have a right of privacy, you have a right of security. Um, I think that goes hand in hand with identifying our cybersecurity infrastructure as a public utility. And that comes with greater, I think we also need to put our money where our mouth is in the context of as a public utility that requires greater investment in the agencies charged with developing minimum standards, enforcing them. There we need to establish what the rules of the game are. Um, this is a rapidly changing uh ecosystem. We can't really rely upon just we need to be creative. I think is and that means that that takes resources.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I agree. I agree with that. Uh Olivia, what were you gonna say?
SPEAKER_02Just look, this is a tough question to answer. This is because it's you're like we've talked before, you're dealing with competing ideals and priorities. And I'm gonna go back to those those primary basic fundamentals. Re-establishing a strong fundamental structure in cybersecurity will truly eliminate a substantial level of of threat opportunities. And just by eliminating those threat opportunities, you open up the opportunity to more successfully share information and provide information and and be able to manage information more successfully. It's Because cybersecurity is so complex or requires a certain level of complexity to properly implement. This is one question that I've like have thought about a lot. And I it's hard. It's like I don't, there's no answer, in my opinion, in terms of on that that cybersecurity level.
SPEAKER_00I think that here it's Tina again. Brings us to where we started is there's no silver bullet to be able to adapt. And that means confronting things. And I think that we have to be okay with it not being okay and recognizing that and and moving forward. So I just listening to you talk that I was thinking I we can't give a silver bullet. And the fact that if we're looking for a silver bullet, we're missing the plot.
SPEAKER_02Yes, you are, yeah, absolutely. The cybersecurity and of the threats and AI is going to constantly be changing. We have to we have to be able to implement an adaptable model and a sustainable model, and that requires a lot from the human effort, from the individual effort. And those individual pieces are fundamentals in any proper cybersecurity solution. I love that.
SPEAKER_01Although we didn't talk about it this round, we will be covering artificial intelligence or AI at a later date. It's it's such a vast and interesting topic that as of right now, there is no real solution to protect ourselves from potential threats. And we all know the concerns about AI. So this closing question is for us rallying all together to find and be part of concrete solutions and to open the door for the next potential episode where we will bring Olivia back. But in the realm of cybersecurity and AI, where solutions are multifaceted and the threats landscape is ever evolving. Olivia, we'll start with you. What's one piece of advice or call to action you'd like to leave the listeners with? How can individuals and organizations contribute to bolstering cybersecurity defenses amidst the complexities of AI advancements and the persistent challenges posed by cyber threats?
SPEAKER_02There's a number of things we can do to stay on top of these ever-evolving challenges on an individual level. And we've talked about them already. I'll reiterate them again is understanding what the primary, what the basics of cybersecurity attacks look like, understanding what phishing looks like, having strong password management, also being careful with your information and how you manage it on a personal level. Because with the AI perspective, what you're seeing is this, like the voice authorization, for example, you can some hospitals are already using, you can do a voice authorized passcode to get health information or set up appointments or talk to your doctor or things like that. Um, but then we know that AI, in terms of a threat situation or a threat actor users utilizing AI, can use that voice and apply an AI technology to it to pretend to be you. And what does that really look like? And how's that going to actually affect the the situation that we're in now? Um, so understanding that that's gonna take place, it's happening, it's going to happen. So understanding essentially that your own individuality and where you live and how you exist and your social media and things like that can be used against you, just plain and simple. And then, like I've said before, it's just understanding, and this just isn't a super exciting answer. It's just understanding the basics of cybersecurity and your own management of your own information. So what you do on a daily basis, well, setting up your multi-factor authentication, et cetera, understanding who to go to if you have a question about your own network and if you think you've been phished or if something's going on, or you think you have a malware situation or anything like that, what to do, who to talk to. Because sometimes that that response action, how quickly you respond and how quickly you get someone to help you with that is going to be a huge factor in the effect of that attack or incidence. These aren't like like we've we've mentioned these these kinds of answers in these sort of situations aren't super like super sexy. They're just it's just the basics of managing your own information and your own responsibility on that level of cybersecurity. And and as we've touched on, it requires an a level of management from the the organization itself of implementing and training and providing resources to the team and the individuals. But that's it. That's that's what's that's what you can do today. That's it.
SPEAKER_01I think one thing too is also building the habit of protecting yourself. We all have the habit of locking the door before we leave. I think that's the same kind of concept that we need to build the habit so that we are always protected. Like we know why we lock the door when we leave. So why can't we do the same thing with our cyber protections?
SPEAKER_00I think I'd add this is not something that Olivia gave a very good example of like what an individual can do and an individual actor, but also ask for help. This is not something that this is a shared responsibility and it it's something that you do need expert assistance in, and it is daunting. And so not to not to be ashamed if you do fail the phishing test by the penetration test and company, but but to ask for help. And then so that's what you can do today, and as to what we can do tomorrow, Olivia, you talked about how recognizing we're all working within a system. This is a human problem, this is a social problem. To solve it, since there's no silver bullet, it's going to take multiple solutions across our society. I mean, it's going to meet new regulations, new investment in an infrastructure. Um, and it's it's going to change, it's going to require a way that we collectively think about our data as our data and that that security.
SPEAKER_01I like both those answers. I feel I feel like we're at a starting point where we can start talking about getting the solution together. Solutions. Sorry. I I have a hard time putting everything into one word, but putting the solutions together so we can start seeing change. And I really think it would be a great idea to get this started before 2029.
SPEAKER_02I would get in there. They're just now finally, they're just gonna start doing the stick instead of the carrot for the regulation.
SPEAKER_01Well, we'll have to see how that works. We'll be back to talk about the rapid rising uses of artificial intelligence and the implications of doing so, but for now, stay on the lookout, my friends. Don't get caught fishing. The Odromatous Way is produced by me, Liz Church. Editorial assistance for this episode was by Olivia, Tina, and myself. This was a collaborative effort to bring you a well-rounded conversation about the importance of cybersecurity and how we need to work together to find solutions, not the silver bullet. Thank you again, you both, for joining me on this endeavor, and I'm really looking forward to the next one. This podcast is part of Adromatus, a boutique consulting firm with the imperative mission of creating healthier, more resilient, more equitable communities. I encourage all of you to reach out and get to know us. You can listen to all of our previous episodes on our website, adromatusconsulting.com slash adromatus dash way. That is A T R O M I T O S. We can also be found on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, or wherever you get your podcasts. We'll see you next time.